It has dumbfounded me for sometime; so much so that I had to write about it. What I am referring to is how illogical it is to sue the government for something a government official/employee did or did not do. It appears that most people think suing the government for some perceived wrong is the right thing to do, but it really is not. Think about it. Or better yet, let me break it down for you with reference to a government “bad” that has been in the news currently. I am talking about the thousands of young Americans who over decades were forcibly sterilized and now government plans to compensate them with some dollar amount; $50,000.00.
To begin with, some tax-dollar funded government group/agency is given the power to decide who they can exercise a power over that results in arguably forcible sterilization of those persons. Some committee is gathered together at the tax payers’ expense to decide who is to exercise this power and when. Then more tax dollars are spent paying the empowered individual(s) to make individual case-by-case determinations. Then more tax dollars are spent enforcing the sterilization on the alleged victims. Then more tax dollars are spent on performing the sterilization itself. Then years later, when some one complains and there is money to be made, a law suit is born. Lawyers are hired on both sides and and more tax dollars are spent. The lawyers on the government side don’t want to hand out any more tax dollars than necessary, so more tax dollars are spent paying the government lawyers to decide how they can payout less. Then a dollar amount is decided on and where do you think that money comes from? The government doesn’t print new money. The government officials involved in the alleged wrong doing don’t pay anything out of their pockets. No the government officials/agencies involved in the alleged wrong walk away having made their money on the alleged wrong. They walk away unscathed. But someone pays, right? Of course someone pays; you and me pay with more tax dollars. We did nothing wrong and yet we pay. Even the individuals collecting pay. Because the money has to come from somewhere and the alleged wrong doing officials aren’t going to pay it. The money comes out of tax-funded programs available for the needy. The money comes from raised taxes on all of us. Why is this? This is because our government has built immunity into itself allowing government officials to do or not do things that may at some future date be considered wrong and compensable. So think twice before suing the government. YOU may become rich, but your new found wealth will be at the expense of all of us innocent tax payers who are barely able to pay our bills and cannot afford another tax hike.
Oh, and just in case you are one of those people who respond by saying, “well, you know in our form of government you elected those government officials and so we must collectively pay for the alleged wrong.” I have this to say. We do not choose the individuals in office. We can only vote for the names put in front of us. They decide to run or – worse – are appointed. Committees are formed, not by our vote. Laws are put into force, not by our vote. We do not live in a democracy. We live in a republic, which is becoming increasingly more totalitarian. We should not be blamed for wrong doings by elected officials – and most assuredly we should not be blamed for wrong doings by appointed officials. For tax payers to be at fault, the alleged wrong doing should be the result of a law created by popular vote and then only those who voted for it should join in the fault. And even more blame should be heaped on those people who carried it out. But that is not how it works in our form of government. And the case in point brings up another flaw in suing the tax payer; many of those accused of doing the wrong doing are dead. In a case for an alleged wrong that happened many years ago, many of the tax payers who foot the bill for the alleged wrong may not even have been old enough to vote or even alive at the time the government officials committed the alleged wrong; and, yet they pay. This is illogical and it is wrong! It is similar to blaming my six-month-old child for slavery because she is white.
Do not get me wrong. I agree, in the case at hand, that those people sterilized should not have been forcibly sterilized. In my opinion, it was wrong! What I disagree with is suing me and my family and my friends and my neighbors for something we did not do and we could not prevent from happening. It is illogical, it is wrong, and it is merely more government officials doing more wrongs. Using tax dollars to pay for their wrong doings.
Help keep this Blog alive by making a small donation
